I wasn’t always an internet slacktivist, and I’ve been thinking about that a lot lately. I think about my feminism and activism now and compare it to my self and way of being 10, 11, 12 years ago. From age 16-21 or so, I could and did happily and easily identify as a riot grrrl after a few years of already calling myself a feminist. But back then, in those days, my feminism and my activism were different. They were a gnarled, unfurling, thick-barked branch, rough and unhewn. I can still say that the burning desire to live in a world where people are equal no matter how they identify on the gender spectrum is still important to me, drivingly, achingly so. But the look and feel of how I go about things has changed drastically, for various reasons.
We used to rally, get on our feet and walk out our doors and stand together and stomp our feet, demanding to be heard. We used to feed homeless people in the park. We used to dumpster dive for free organic veggies for our vegan pitch-ins. We made our own non-toxic glue and had a screenprint for the posters we would make in our guerilla feminist tactics. We shred on our guitars, abstained from shaving (still mostly do) to eschew the patriarchy, we traded books and talked about them ’til all hours of the night, we picked up and just went. We were reckless, tireless, and always poor.
But there is no ‘we’ anymore. Not the we that I was part of back then. I separated from that we years ago. I’m talking about a group of friends, a cohort, and not a single partner. Though I suppose that when a group is really tight-knit they become like a partner, in a way. When I first started moving away from that group of friends, it was because I felt stagnant. We were a puddle of still water in the base of a tire, collecting mosquitoes in the humid summer swell. The same thing would happen every day without change or inspiration. The talks died out, the books stopped being read, everything became fashion. More importantly, many of them started doing hard drugs. I drink. While I will openly and readily advocate for bodily autonomy, I won’t pretend that I will be happy to sit in a room with people who close the curtains every day after work, get high, fuzz out, and think of nothing else, do nothing else. We were becoming tepid and lukewarm, complacent in our own lives and existence. As I moved away from that group, I ended up with one of those wonky 40hr/wk jobs, and that’s still what I have going on. Those jobs. Once you start, you can become locked in. I feel locked in.
And it is interesting, looking back, to see what kind of a change my work schedule and upcoming university schedule had on my activism. Separating from friends would have an impact, I knew. College and work, however, I didn’t think would cause such a difference. The hours in the day go by and then you go to class at night, do schoolwork, only actively go out into the streets or your community on available saturdays. Being an activist becomes something you schedule in, which isn’t really very active. I received an e-mail the other day asking me some of my thoughts on capitalism and feminism. I am not addressing those topics in their entirety in this post, but the obvious angle is patriarchy, the male gaze, materialism and consumerism. What is also interesting, however, is the effect that operating within our current capitalist structure has on our availability, ambition, and ability. When you look at the ways that patriarchy and capitalism are best friends and yearning, aching lovers, and you look at the goals of feminism (equality for all people, wherever they fall on the gender spectrum), it is immediately apparent that patriarchy within the kyriarchy must be toppled. It is less evident at first glance that capitalism, also, is an enemy of feminism. If the burning flame of that riot grrrl and her life-my life-are still combusting eternally within me, not yet given to embers, what has changed? The jobs that I have had have had a tremendous impact on my availability. I have fallen into the cycle of created need and desire. When the local woman’s shelter needs supplies, I give them money, or the items they need. I do not give them my physical time. Partially that is due to the experience being too triggering and traumatic, and I am not yet personally there. On the other hand, it’s easy for me to donate towels, diapers, formula. When I think of this I always think of Zizek saying ‘It is immoral to use private property in order to alleviate the horrible evils that result from the institution of private property’. Though not perfectly, it does relate here. Meanwhile, what am I doing to end rape culture or spread awareness of domestic violence issues?
But does that entirely matter, or, should that be the crux of the matter? I’m blogging now. Writing. I hear at least once a week in my classes a tone of derision toward internet activism, to blogging, to social media. It’s seen as petty, trivial, and small. When I hear that, I don’t feel defeated or unnecessary. I feel that sparking flame ignite within me. If one person reads one thing here and it sparks them to think differently, won’t that have an impact on the people around them based on how they act? I do not think that web activism is inefficient. If a group of people harness their time and energy and strength together to rally and meet in person, they have done a great thing, and I give them credit. If a group of people harness their time, energy and strength together to rally and meet and spread information through the ether, making it easily accessible to many who might otherwise never have found it, they have also done a great thing and I cannot discredit this action. I do not think that either way of communicating ideas and working for social change has less intrinsic value than the other. I think that our world is changing, our ways of communicating effectively and on a large scale are changing, and that the key to effecting social change and doing our part in any way we can is in being adaptable and focusing on what we can do. And though sometimes I may feel like I don’t know where that grrrl is anymore, I’m still right here, doing things in a different way, rioting on these keys.
cafeaulait13
/ November 27, 2012Thank you for defending blogging and internet “slactivism.” Actually, I really hate that term “slacktivist.” I mean, it’s not like we can single handedly dismantle the world; we need allies. Spreading awareness is how we gain them.
So keep on with your inner riot girrl.
Sara
/ November 27, 2012I also hate the term ‘slacktivist’. I don’t know many,or I guess any people that have been called that who self-identify that way.
This post was written after a lot of holiday conversation and introspection. The holiday was good, but weird. And you are spot on about needing allies. Furthering the discourse and continuing the conversation are things I consider to be good and worth doing, for sure!
robin claire
/ November 27, 2012We don’t see eye-to-eye in our spiritual views, but I love the way you write Sara. You are one of the most gifted writers/bloggers I have ever read – and I follow many, many blogs. I just wanted you to know that.
robin claire
Sara
/ November 27, 2012Thank you, Robin. That’s really nice and I appreciate it immensely!
kvarm
/ November 27, 2012Unlike Robin, I don’t follow many blogs but precisely because most seem diluted and rather directionless to me (not yours). I have read many over the years and studied social media years ago.
Thanks for your perspective! Surviving is my full-time job right now – a more accurate way to put it than to say I’m unemployed. The concept of ‘slacktivism’ may apply to some (depends a lot on what they’re saying and arguably applies to pointless real-life activism) but it would be an insult to me and many disabled folks, the activism scene may not care to be accessible and people may be in different circumstances. There has been a process of ‘erasing’ my voice from two communities in which I have been for years because calling-out oppression is too radical for radical communities, who knew! I’m rioting more now than when I was participating in those and it’s not a mere impression.
I share your observation of doing activism with a team and the impact of drugs. I wasn’t happy about the waste of time but more importantly, I got a disorder from their second-hand smoke. It’s been my biggest handicap. As for my ex-team, they’ve either lost their mind completely or lost interest in activism, even personal activism.
Sara
/ November 27, 2012I think the term slacktivism is demeaning and belittling, absolutely. I’ve never viewed it as a compliment or positive thing and I haven’t met anybody that would. (That I know of) the root word is ‘slacker’, right? Which implies that the person working for social change in whatever way they are isn’t really ‘doing’ anything. I definitely disagree with that. You raise an excellent point about disabled folks and I appreciate you bringing it up. It can be really hard to see ourselves clearly enough to dismantle and deconstruct our own privilege, and I didn’t even think about how it could be used in that capacity. I’m really glad you shared that perspective.
I disliked the waste of time, but also the personal stagnation and the lack of growth and development. It is such a depressing environment. Tomorrow, today, yesterday, they’re all the same and nothing is dynamic, everything is static. I can’t hang with that. That sucks that you got a disorder from their second hand smoke! That’s awful! Most of the people I hung out with back in those days have dispersed to various places around the country, but they’ve mostly lost an interest in activism or are still too busy doing drugs to have an opinion on it.
Another community wherein I see the calling out of oppression being trivialized or minimized is within feminist spheres. WoC tend to be grossly underrepresented and when it is pointed out, I see a lot of pushback. I don’t get it.
kvarm
/ November 27, 2012Sorry, my sentence hardly made sense, I’m in caffeine-withdrawal mode today! I meant to have suggested something about reclaiming ‘slacktivism’ to describe for instance what PETA does (I don’t see they can help anyone using misogyny, it’s not even one step forward two backs, it only helps their bank accounts!), unless that’s ‘detractivism’. I’ll go write a blog entry. Yeah the root word is ‘slacker’.
From very little of it in fact, and I run one of a few support-groups for Depersonalisation disorder. It’s very common to get it from THC and some other drugs, but often mis-diagnosed and under-researched.
I have been thinking a lot about gaslighting and wondering how to call that behaviour when it applies to what you decribe for instance. It’s hard for me to distinguish which part of me is under attack as a queer disabled female vegan of colour, some groups tried to use me as token and censor me at the same time. Some end up branching off instead of joining one big “happy” community.
‘Happy activists’ by Black, Broken and Bent, on my list of likes, is a good piece on accessibility and exclusion.
Whit
/ November 27, 2012As usual, I am right there with you. In my younger days I felt like I was SO involved. I was always at meetings or events, cheering and jeering with the best of them. And then I graduated. I started doing the 40hr/week thing. I started grad school. I closed my account with the First Bank of Mom and Dad. So now I blog. And the funny thing is, I feel like now my message is more focused, more potent, and reaches a much wider audience who can take it and run with it. Of course, sometimes I am even to busy to blog (see my recent 3 week hiatus, which ends tonight!), and sometimes I do kind of have to “schedule” my activism. But I’m still here, dammit. And I still care. And I still share.
Sara
/ November 27, 2012I hear ya. I actually think more people hear what I’m saying now than before.
rosettesandrevolution
/ November 28, 2012You’re gonna change the world. You already are. Times change, and the way we choose to exercise our activism changes with it. Slacktivism isn’t a thing. And if it isn’t a thing, it certainly isn’t you. Keep rioting, sister!
emmamulligan
/ November 29, 2012*ahem* I hereby nominate you for the Sunshine Award! Please consult this page for more [http://runesandrhinestones.wordpress.com/2012/11/23/sunshine-award-time-to-procrastinate/]
Sara
/ November 29, 2012That’s the nicest thing ever! Thank you!
Penny Dreadful
/ November 29, 2012Capitalism is intrinsically a system of inequality, such that it really does counter every effort at activism in the end. Not that it’s impossible to change things, just that it sneaks into everything to where eventually a movement will sort of eat itself. But activism IS change, so I don’t see how changing the format of activism is out of line with that. You can’t keep doing exactly the same thing and expect it to make the same difference it made at the beginning. It’s unsustainable. Whether it takes weeks, months, years, or decades, every movement changes and I think it’s mostly for the good. It gives young people a chance to make their own mark, and it gives olders a chance to refresh, to become re-inspired. Enemies of change abound in all walks of life because change is scary! Even people who are trying to change something else, like Capitalism or Patriarchy, get bogged down by the uncomfortable growing pains that are necessary. So you get people who look down on new forms of activism.
Internet Feminism is how I got into the whole shebang. I came around a bit late, fully into college, but it blew my fucking mind open and I haven’t stopped since. And for me, just hearing so many different people’s voices keeps me thinking, keeps me empathetic, keeps me passionate. Silence and stagnation are killers. Everything else is gravy.